3 Comments
User's avatar
Nate's avatar

I have to disagree about your assessment of Trump. I think he's far closer to a Hitler, Mussolini, Stalin or at least Orban and less of a Morawiecki than we might hope for. In those cases "the wind" did more than rattle a few windows, it left a swathe of destruction that took years to clean up and fundamentally reshaped the world. Those storms are rare in the extreme, but they're happening more frequently of late, as are the partisan politics that are subtly altering the rivers of political discourse world-wide. Remember, I suppose, that reshaping the course of the Nile can also bring down empires, at least for a time.

Expand full comment
John Wesley Chisholm's avatar

I understand your position and was cognizant when I was writing that I was writing against this common view of things, which you have well articulated.

Expand full comment
Nate's avatar

Liberal, maybe. I don't think my view is actually "common" given how close the numbers seem to be. Or at least I don't think "common" or "average" people truly understand how devastating a political demagogue can actually be, given that most of them haven't actually lived through one. I imagine the common view is broadly similar in Russia too because people generally have a hard time (in my experience) viewing the broader picture from (a state sponsored) limited perspective. It's one of the ways social media and state sponsored disinformation campaigns have skewed or spun what is actually factual toward false narratives. It may, in fact, be one of the reasons social media is allowed. It's become relatively easy to influence swathes of people to believe in total bullshit.

Expand full comment