A Brief Report on the Lobster Economy

What's the Worst The Could Happen?

Potential and Impact of a 25% U.S. Tariff on Nova Scotia Lobster Imports

Background:
Nova Scotia’s lobster fishery is a cornerstone of the province’s economy, contributing over $1 billion annually to exports. The United States is the primary market, purchasing approximately 70% of Nova Scotia's lobster exports. A proposed 25% tariff on lobster imports by the U.S. in early 2025 poses a significant threat to the industry's profitability and competitiveness.

---

Potential Impact:

1. Economic Losses:

   • A 25% tariff would increase costs for U.S. buyers, likely leading to decreased demand for Nova Scotia lobster.

   • Price reductions may occur as exporters attempt to remain competitive, reducing revenues for harvesters and processors.

   • Potential annual revenue losses could exceed $250 million.

2. Market Diversification Challenges:

   • While Nova Scotia has made inroads into European and Asian markets (via agreements like CETA), these markets cannot fully absorb the U.S. shortfall in the short term.

   • European markets impose additional sustainability and traceability requirements, creating barriers to rapid expansion.

3. Supply Chain Pressure:

   • Lower demand could lead to oversupply, causing price collapses that ripple through the supply chain, from fishermen to distributors.

   • Smaller operators are particularly vulnerable, risking closures or job losses.

4. Geopolitical Tensions:

   • The tariff could strain Canada-U.S. trade relations, potentially prompting Federal retaliatory measures or disputes under agreements like USMCA out of Nova Scotia’s control.

---

Potential Mitigation Strategies:

1. Trade Negotiations:

   • Federal advocacy for tariff exemptions or reductions through diplomatic channels is essential.

   • Leverage USMCA dispute mechanisms if the tariff violates trade agreements.

2. Market Diversification: No short term solutions

   • Accelerate efforts to expand Asian markets, particularly China, which values premium seafood.

   • Increase investment in marketing lobster as a high-value product globally.

3. Industry Adaptation: No short term solutions

   • Support innovations in lobster processing and value-added products to appeal to new markets.

   • Provide short-term financial support or subsidies to sustain the industry during the adjustment period.

---

Conclusion:
A 25% U.S. tariff on Nova Scotia lobster imports would have severe economic, social, and geopolitical consequences. To mitigate risks, targeted trade negotiations, diversification of export markets, and industry adaptation are critical but there are few short term solutions if a tariff is imposed. Without proactive measures, the tariff could destabilize one of Nova Scotia’s most iconic and vital industries.

Seafood Alliance spokesperson Stewart Lamont says “This is arguably the most important week of the year in the Atlantic Canadian lobster business.”

About 1800 commercial fishers have returned to the water.

“You cannot imagine the ‘horsepower’ these folks bring to our sector. 25-35 million pounds could be caught in the next five weeks, weather permitting.

What is amazing is the utter lack of enthusiasm on the Dealer side. The flood gates of supply are opening and most companies are more nervous than ever before in their commercial history.

For good reason their bankers are plenty nervous as well.

“Yes, it has to do with the fundamentals: catch, quality, cost and market. But it also has to do with the incredibly unstable world in which we operate. For those who are risk averse, the current climate is desperate.”

Worst Case Scenario

The worst-case scenario of a 25% U.S. tariff on Nova Scotia lobster imports would be catastrophic for the province, its fishing communities, and lobster dealers. The U.S., accounting for 70% of Nova Scotia’s lobster exports, would likely reduce its purchases drastically, leading to a surplus of unsold product. This oversupply would drive prices down to unsustainable levels, crippling fishers' and dealers’ incomes. Smaller operators, unable to absorb the financial losses or pivot quickly to alternative markets, would be forced out of business. Entire coastal communities, heavily reliant on the lobster industry, could face economic collapse, with widespread unemployment and financial hardship driving workers to leave in search of other opportunities. The social fabric of these communities, closely tied to fishing as a way of life, could unravel under the strain, exacerbating mental health challenges and increasing poverty.

The economic fallout would ripple through related industries, including gear suppliers, logistics companies, and shipbuilders, amplifying the damage across the province. Nova Scotia’s reputation as a supplier of premium seafood could also suffer, as surplus lobster is dumped into the market at discounted prices. This loss of trust among international buyers could make it difficult to rebuild the market, even if the tariff were later removed. Trade relations between Canada and the U.S. could deteriorate if retaliatory tariffs were imposed, potentially sparking a broader trade conflict that harms other sectors of the economy. Meanwhile, desperation among fishers could lead to overfishing or unsustainable practices, putting additional pressure on lobster stocks and raising environmental concerns.

To sum it up, the tariff’s impact would devastate Nova Scotia’s economy, fracture its fishing communities, and undermine its long-term economic and environmental sustainability. Without immediate action to diversify markets, negotiate trade solutions, and support affected industries, even today as the boats head out, the province could face a crisis of unprecedented scale.